Edward fesers imaginary knockout of new atheism atheist. Edward feser just released a new book, titled five proofs of the existence of god ignatius press, 2017. An alternative view of edward fesers aristotles case for. Edward feser s imaginary knockout of new atheism by larry tanner apr 20, 2014 74 comments a more pointed and descriptive headline for this essay is feser comes on like apollo creed from rocky iii, but winds up as apollo creed from rocky iv. A refutation of the new atheism sets the tone for the entire work, as it asserts in bold letters across the cover that atheism is the ultimate superstition. Edward feser project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks. Mary of the lake edward feser, a philosopher at pasadena city college francis j. Slowly but surely, philosopher edward feser contends, philosophers of science are rediscovering a need for teleology in the universe over three and a half centuries after theyd ruled it out. Now, i am sympathetic to the arguments of the intelligent design school and appreciate william dembskis and his discovery institute colleagues efforts to show that darwinian natural selection is not. I have enjoyed a series of essays on the patheos web site by bradley bowen. To use another thomist concept, it is only so far as a regular pattern of use can be determined that it is possible to make suitable judgements about the meaning of at metaphysics. Feser parts significantly with contemporary intelligent design theorists who mount a case for theism by first conceding the mechanistic picture, then proposing. Moreland, distinguished professor of philosophy, biola university. This argument from design, as given by paley and unfortunately repeated in many books on christian apologetics.
As this book demonstrates, there is precious little science behind the intelligent design movement, but there is a great deal of politics and religion. Some id advocates are frontloaders, who believe god set up the initial conditions of the cosmos in a highly specific way, so as to make gootoyou evolution possible at least, on the physical level, without the need for any acts of. The academic defenders of the intelligent design argument make some philosophical assumptions about the nature of creation that feser disagrees with. The best books on the existence of god ed feser on five. Taking aquinas seriously edward feser first things.
Edward feser, the last superstition, an unpublishable. Five proofs of the existence of god paperback august 18, 2017. The best books on arguments against creationism five books. If you are puzzled by matter, form, act, potency, and so on, then this is the book for you. Feser criticizes ids idea of god as a designer, arguing. Ed, on his personal blog, published an analysis of intelligent design theory in which he shows how much it shares philosophically with the darwinian mechanistic view of nature. O ne of the greatest services of aristotles revenge, and of dr. Morgan gives special attention to the criticisms of intelligent design theory that i raise in that chapter.
This criticism falls out of a mechanistic understanding of nature. Below youll find our favorite books in several categories. Ed feser december 27, 2017 in podcast by frank turek a fantastic interview with prolific writer and professor of philosophy, dr. One of my favorite philosophers is the alwaysinteresting edward feser. Balancing intelligent design and philosophy worldview of. The metaphysical foundations of physical and biological science 2019.
Ed feser, who btw also thinks intelligent design believers are idiots, is fighting another battle with very little overlap. Of course, evolution, which is an entirely impersonal natural process, doesnt really design anything. Michael shermer and the laws of complexity evolution news. Ed feser on nothing but, intelligent design, and the. Edward feser on mathematics and the sense of the divine. It entails that god is immutable or changeless, and therefore that he is impassible that is, that he cannot be affected by anything in the created order. Moreover, i argue that fesers notion of immanent teleology owes more to aristotle than to thomas or anything essential to catholic theology. Fesers battlefield is metaphysics and the supposed decline of western civilisation due to modernist philosophy. I think that edward feser is an excellent philosopher. Feser criticizes intelligent design theory on a number of grounds. Edward feser about his new book five proofs of the existence of god. The fields of philosophy of religion and analytic theology show a great amount of sophistication and conceptual richness, so why arent the new atheists engaging with these arguments. Feser says it could be but he argues against naturalistic evolution anyway. Beckwith, a philosopher at baylor university page 2.
Second, that intelligent design theory assumes a form of reductionism that things are reducible to their microstructures. During the debate, a caller commented on the improbability of the undirected appearance of life. While feser differs from intelligent design theorists on his approach to the question, he agrees with the conclusion that nature evidences the existence of a mind instilling. While feser differs from intelligent design theorists on his approach to the question, he agrees with the conclusion that nature evidences the existence of a mind instilling purpose, goaldirectedness, and function within nature. And since god designed the world and science is against intelligent design, then science must be both atheistic and wrong. A fantastic interview with prolific writer and professor of philosophy, dr. As dembski correctly says, the essential idea behind these terms is that information is conferred on an object from outside the object and that the material constituting the object, apart from that outside information, does not.
Purpose and essence in nature posted on july 15, 2019 july 15, 2019 on this episode of id the future, michael egnor interviews philosopher edward feser about feser s new book aristotles revenge. In the latters argument the universe is seen as a complicated and intricate machine and he reasons, by way of analogy, to the existence of a divine watchmaker, or supreme architect of the universe. And this is leading them back to aristotle and his theories of forms and causes just as many centuries after theyd banished him from the edward feser. The doctrine of divine simplicity has a number of crucial implications, which are, accordingly, also essential to classical theism.
One of the most influential philosophers and theologians in the history of western thought, st thomas aquinas established the foundations for much of modern philosophy of religion, and is infamous for his arguments for the existence of god. The fact that fesers book aristotles revenge is so long is evidence that at metaphysics is nonsense, i. A contemporary introduction, five proofs of the existence of god, and the coauthor. I will now present some paragraphs from two books written by classical. Pasadena city college associate professor edward feser s new book. Feser has given us a book which is in a class by itself for clarity. Intelligent design does not presuppose that the designer of nature broke any natural laws in the process of producing us. The fact is that secularists are for reason and science only to the extent that they dont lead to religious conclusions. Ai delusion book, city journal, edward feser, featured, gary smith if computers are intelligent, climbing a tree is flying that, says edward feser, is the takehome message from gary smiths book, the ai delusion news september 9, 2019 artificial intelligence, philosophy of mind. I also think that his criticisms of intelligent design theory are criticisms of the philosophical. A refutation of the new atheism, that is not entirely the case. I reached the end of feser s book, 1 and discovered that he addressed this issue of theodicy in two more places.
This book is a mustread for anyone interested in natural theology. Dembski here identifies design with what aristotle called techne or art. Personal explanation in natural theology and intelligent design 74. God, creation, design, and science gore burnelli medium. Feser s issue with intelligent design is not against the idea that god is the designer of all creation. Ed feser on nothing but, intelligent design, and the mechanistic philosophy of nature one of my favorite philosophers is the alwaysinteresting edward feser. As dembski correctly says, the essential idea behind these terms is that information is conferred on an object from outside the object and that the material constituting. A common saying in philosophy is that you can read a book and enjoy it very much, even if you agree with not a word of it. Materialism is a whole battery of blatant fallacies. Feser effortlessly demolishes the gross philosophical ignorance of. Edward feser, with links to his blog posts and lectures on philosophy, written with lively clarity.
First, that intelligent design theory assumes a philosophy of nature that is mechanistic. In the case of edward feser s the last superstition. It is not just that secularists happen to reject and oppose religion. For example, throughout the book, dennett makes assertions to the effect that evolution designed this or that. Never fear, dear reader, we really are through with the intelligent design id versus aristotelicothomism at debate for a while, and will now return to the regular mix of posts on philosophy, theology, breathtakingly reactionary politics and pretentious pop culture analysis.
Catholics and intelligent design, part one evolution news. He recently spoke with first things junior fellow connor grubaugh about three of his favorite books in the field. A refutation of the new atheism, aquinas, scholastic metaphysics. The esteemed lydia mcgrew, a friend of this blog, wonders whether my defense of classical theism and criticisms of intelligent design theory can be reconciled with some of the miracle stories one finds in the bible. Throughout his book, feser stresses that aquinass five ways proofs for the existence of god, outlined briefly at the start of the summa theologiae, are not aquinass most complete treatment of this topic, but rather that his ideas on this topic are expanded and developed throughout all his works.
Edward feser on the question of mind behind the universe. An alternative view of edward fesers discussion of. Feser from his sharply reasoned posts here at strange notions, or from his popular blog, which mainly focuses on the philosophy of religion. Here i want to explore in more detail the topic of creation and design, in a way. Feser brings to discussions about terms and concepts. A refutation of the new atheism is a provocative polemic that manages to skillfully do exactly what it sets out to do. Feser s main point is that, at least for catholics, id is hopelessly devoid of solid metaphysical grounding. I recently came across a couple of unique insights on how some even classical christian theists object to intelligent design id as being a god of the gaps or argument from ignorance fallacy while reading the last superstition. You are going in the direction of the silly multiverse atheist escape clause. Recently on the michael medved show, atheist michael shermer debated catholic philosopher edward feser. I think he must realize that this issue is the one that undermines all his arguments, but he isnt. Intelligent design, edward fesers views philosophy. An alternative view of edward feser s aristotles case for god in his book.
The metaphysical foundations of physical and biological sciences, the last superstition. Edward feser is widely recognized as a top scholar in the history of philosophy in general, and in thomistic and aristotelian philosophy in particular. I enjoyed all of the book, but i strongly disagreed with the last quarter of the book. Conventional descriptions of material processes do not help much when we are trying to account for abstract thought. Recently, atheist michael shermer debated catholic philosopher edward feser. The subject was feser s new book on five arguments for the existence of god. Edward feser 1968 is a catholic christian apologist writer of books such as aristotles revenge. Edward feser is associate professor of philosophy at pasadena city college, where he writes and teaches on contemporary analytic philosophy from a thomistic perspective. From aristotle through aquinas to the present, professor ed feser gives. Edward feser, associate professor of philosophy at pasadena city college in pasadena, california, seeks to free us from such a tyranny in his remarkable book the last superstition. An alternative view of edward feser s discussion of theodicy in his book.
Find all the books, read about the author, and more. This is a popularization of contemporary philosophy, a piece of cultural criticism, a history of. This alone may tell you whether or not this book is for you or not it introduces feser s polemic style, and it also tells you its goal. Edward feser quotes author of the last superstition. The philosopher argues against naturalistic evolution, while differing from intelligent design theorists in his approach to the question. In this cogent and multifaceted introduction to the great saints work, edward feser argues that you cannot fully understand aquinas philosophy without. Rather, i want to make sure that i fully understand fesers general position regarding design, creation, and the christian god. Third, fesers book is better because it understands modern thinkers and their objections to aquinas. The title of edward feser s book the last superstition. First, edward feser, professor of philosophy at pasadena college, began posting a series of essays showing up the hollow philosophical shell at the heart of intelligent design.
364 448 1200 1138 1143 992 499 331 15 13 545 803 773 17 841 1432 4 222 1207 1075 891 659 1502 1100 1349 883 54 1440 15 1001 784 888 1366 453